You are not logged in.

1

Tuesday, January 16th 2007, 11:55pm

Default drag and drop action

Can I set a default action for drag n drop so that I am not prompted to copy, move, or cancel each time?

I realize I could just use the keyboard modifiers, but I find that very awkward and unfriendly.

bram85

Professional

Posts: 948

Location: Eindhoven

Occupation: Software Engineer

  • Send private message

2

Wednesday, January 17th 2007, 11:54am

RE: Default drag and drop action

No you can't. The current behavior is chosen in order to prevent surprises.
Bram Schoenmakers
KDE Netherlands (www.kde.nl)

3

Wednesday, January 17th 2007, 9:02pm

RE: Default drag and drop action

I certainly appreciate the work you all do, and I don't want to seem un-appreciative or unfriendly, but it kinda sounds like you are making the decision for me because maybe you think we (as in kde users) aren't intelligent enough to make this decision for ourselves.

In my opinion, that kind of philosophy belongs only in a place like micro$oft. I'd rather re-compile an app. 100 times, search through a thousand forums, and beg dev's for advice than ever have a decision made for me based on the belief that I'm too stupid to make it for myself.

That being said, I don't plan on moving away from kde, I just wish I could have a little more control.

Thanks anyways.

4

Thursday, January 18th 2007, 8:42am

RE: Default drag and drop action

Quoted

Originally posted by jckdnk111
I certainly appreciate the work you all do, and I don't want to seem un-appreciative or unfriendly, but it kinda sounds like you are making the decision for me because maybe you think we (as in kde users) aren't intelligent enough to make this decision for ourselves.

keep in mind that this is a user forum, not a developer <-> user forum.

So 'you' does not really apply on any of the audience over here, i don't expect the developer of that feature reads this forum.

You could create a bug report against konqueror at bugs.kde.org requesting for this feature to be configurable.

tha way you can be sure that the proper kde developers are reading it and you can follow the progress of your request online at bugs.kde.org

Regards, Rinse
Help mee om KDE 3.5.5 in het Nederlands te vertalen

bram85

Professional

Posts: 948

Location: Eindhoven

Occupation: Software Engineer

  • Send private message

5

Thursday, January 18th 2007, 11:16am

RE: Default drag and drop action

Quoted

In my opinion, that kind of philosophy belongs only in a place like micro$oft.


Wrong, nearly every software project makes assumptions for the user. This is not Microsoft only, look at Gnome (which is much worse in that aspect than KDE).

Quoted

That being said, I don't plan on moving away from kde, I just wish I could have a little more control.


KDE generally offers you far more control than our neighbors (bluntly GNOME or Windows), by giving the user the choice to move, copy or link (in your example).

If you wish to define every tiny little bit of the desktop fine, but 98% of the users don't care about these options. It's not likely the original developers will work on that, unless someone of the remaining 2% supplies a patch.
Bram Schoenmakers
KDE Netherlands (www.kde.nl)

6

Sunday, December 16th 2007, 8:10pm

I hate to revive an old thread like this, but I have similar issues with this design and wonder if there are alternatives / work-arounds?

The type of work I am doing requires discriminating, manipulating, and copying thousands of small files individually (one at a time) and the pop-up menu disrupts the workflow immensely. Using the keyboard shortcut is also very awkward because ctl is used for selecting multiple files. So for each file it is either extra keyboard taps or extra clicks to deselect and reselect. It might seem like a small thing to complain about, but it adds up to thousands of extra movements.

toad

Trainee

Posts: 66

Location: capital of beer

  • Send private message

7

Monday, December 17th 2007, 3:21pm

Hi Venner,

I don't quite understand your problem. As far as I can see CTRL + click selects but CTRL + C/X/V does not interfere with the selection process... What am I missing?
running on Debian Etch

8

Sunday, February 10th 2008, 8:36pm

I'm having the exact same problem.

I don't use GUI interfaces to do file manipulation as a general rule. But today I am.

The problem I have is this: If I have a file that is in one directory, and I drag and drop it to another directory, KDE ALWAYS asks me if I want to copy it, move it, link to it, etc, etc.

Why is there no default action?

At the very least it should be possible for a knowledgeable user to configure the default action that they want. (And I don't mean by twiddling a hidden entry in ./kde/share/config/xyz1234)

Short of that, a key+mouse combination that will allow users to EXPLICITLY choose which action they want to perform will suffice. For the life of me, I cannot find any such key+mouse combination.